Photo: Talan Torriero/instagram, Stefanie Keenan/Getty Images for CTAOP
Laguna Beachis the gift that keeps on giving for longtime fans as they were treated to a juicy hookup reveal nearly two decades later.
Though Conrad and Cavallari were painted as competitors for Colletti’s heart on the show, the women revealed on Tuesday’s podcast that castmate Talon Torriero was actually the one they were both “hooking up” while filming the show’s first season.
Emma McIntyre/Getty; Mindy Small/Getty; Gregg DeGuire/Getty
“The producers were all swaying us in different directions. I feel like Talan just took it upon himself to be that guy,” Cavallari, 35, said of Torriero’s “player” status. “And that’s what I love so much about it.”
“He did,” said Conrad, 36. “But I’ll say this — this is terrible. They were always like, ‘Everybody wants Stephen,’ but, like … I was hooking up with Talan.”
Cavallari chimed in, “We all were.”
Talan Torriero/instagram
And Torriero wasn’t the only guy Conrad revealed she was juggling during herLaguna Beachdays.
“I [had] several boyfriends during this time,” she told Cavallari and Colletti, 36. “Which I’m like, I feel so bad for them if they ever watch this. They were like, ‘Oh man. I’m often kind of off in a corner, just like, creepily watching you guys, which is kind of embarrassing.'”
She continued, “I think one of my takeaways from looking back is I’m like, ‘It’s really sweet.’ You guys were in love and you had a relationship.”
Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories
Nearly two decades after the show’s debut, Torriero is now a family man who shares two kids with wife Danielle Torriero. Conrad has two sons withWilliam Tell, Cavallari is a mother of three with exJay Cutler, and Colletti is in an Instagram-official relationship withAlex Weaver.
source: people.com
